Discrimination

Religion is never an excuse to discriminate. Get rid of religious loopholes that are rolling back hard-won civil rights.

Discrimination takes many forms, and the targets of discrimination are as diverse as the motivations behind it. A secular approach to dealing with discrimination reflects the duality of the religious clauses of the First Amendment. Discrimination is improper when it targets an individual for their beliefs or lack thereof. It is also improper to exempt religiously motivated actions from an otherwise valid anti-discrimination statute, thereby using government protection to endorse a particular religious belief.

History shows that at times only force of law can outweigh popular prejudices. American society has made vast improvements in the past 50 years in combating discrimination, and more Americans are choosing not to hide identities that may target them for abuse and ridicule. As we conquer new grounds of acceptance, conflicts emerge when rights are at odds with each other: namely, that operating in the public square requires compliance with all public laws and religion is only a valid justification for discrimination in the most limited of contexts.

Employment Discrimination: Our government has a long history of subsidizing the efforts of organizations providing social services. Historically, the same laws and regulations regarding how government funds were utilized and the hiring and firing practices for such programs applied to both secular and religious groups. Unfortunately, executive orders from President George W. Bush allow federally funded faith-based organizations to discriminate on the basis of religion in their hiring practices. This is an exemption to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which makes it unlawful for an employer to refuse to hire or fire any individual because of such individual’s religion.

Yet we do not hold salaries paid from taxpayer dollars to faith-based employees to the same standard. Religious organizations providing social services to U.S. citizens should be held to the same non-discrimination policies required of every other federal contractor and grantee. Religious organizations have a right to promote their beliefs and to ask their followers to live lives based on these beliefs. However, when religious organizations accept money from the federal or state governments to provide publicly accessible social services, they must agree to abide by certain regulations prohibiting discrimination against the very taxpayers who fund such activities. Faith-based organizations are not required to apply for or accept taxpayer funds if they believe their religious rights will be compromised.

These principles extend to employment protections for LGBT Americans. In many states it is currently legal for an employee to be fired solely for their sexual orientation or gender identity. In many of the states that have laws protecting LGBT employees there is an exemption for houses of worship, religiously affiliated nonprofits, and businesses. It is important to note that houses of worship are protected by the Constitution and do not require a legislative carve out. However, religiously affiliated hospitals and businesses should be held to the same standards of equality as other employers. No other class of citizens protected by anti-discrimination legislation is subject to such an exemption.

Discrimination in hiring and firing on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation is wrong no matter the motivation. Laws that put religious exemptions in place set a dangerous precedent that religion is a valid justification for hate.

Housing Discrimination: The Fair Housing Act of 1968 contains several important protections to ensure that U.S. citizens are able to purchase housing free from discrimination. However, while the Act protects against discrimination against any one person because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin, it does not protect against discrimination on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation. Unfortunately, this lack of protection has led to numerous cases in which a landlord uses religious reasons, such as a scriptural prohibition on homosexuality, to discriminate against potential and current tenants on the basis of their sexual orientation or gender identity.

A 2017 study by the Urban Institute found that in three major metropolitan areas (Los Angeles, Dallas, and Washington D.C.), gay men and transgendered people were quoted higher prices, given less appointments, and told of fewer available rental units than their straight or non-transgendered counterparts. Still, most states still allow for discrimination against LGBTQ Americans, which can take several forms, including but not limited to: preventing same-sex couples from sharing a lease, preventing same-sex couples from both being on a homeowner’s insurance policy, and the refusal to rent or sell property to same-sex couples or transgender U.S. citizens. Most often, the reason for this discrimination is religious in nature, with landlords claiming that renting to an individual “living in sin” would be a violation of their religious beliefs. The ability to purchase housing free from discrimination must be a fundamental right for all U.S. citizens, regardless of how they look, who they love, or how they identify. Discrimination in housing on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation is wrong no matter the motivation.
A federal law, or amendment to the original Fair Housing Act, should be introduced to add LGBTQ Americans to the protected classes regarding housing discrimination. This law or amendment should not contain any religious exemptions.

Washington, D.C. - The Secular Coalition for America, in partnership with their 20 member organizations, today released to the public their Secular Agenda for the 117th Congress & Biden Administration.

The comprehensive plan includes strengthening and supporting the Congressional Freethought Caucus (CFC), repealing harmful Executive Orders, supporting the nomination and appointments of judges and other government officials who adhere to and actively promote and prioritize the separation of religion and government, bringing further visibility and respect to nontheists, and a slew of legislative priorities. These include the Do No Harm Act, the Scientific Integrity Act, and the CORE Act.

“We are excited to put forth this ambitious plan for the new administration and Congress,” stated Casey Brinck, Director of Policy and Government Affairs for the Secular Coalition for America. “As we move forward into the first session of the 117th Congress, we can expect a flurry of legislative actions to be undertaken, and want not only our community to understand what we are working for on their behalf, but also for Congress and the new administration to have a better understanding of what our very large and quickly growing constituency expects of them.”

Rachel Deitch, Director of Policy and Social Justice for the American Humanist Association, remarked, “We have made significant progress during the past few Congresses on many of our legislative priorities, and we look forward to seeing them pass the finish line in the 117th. While there still will be a difficult fight in Congress, bills like the Do No Harm Act have consistently gained support over the past few years, and we believe now is the time to see them on President-elect Biden’s desk.”

The Coalition will also be working to strengthen and aid the Congressional Freethought Caucus in their mission to promote public policy formed on the basis of reason, science, and moral values, while opposing discrimination against atheists, agnostics, humanists, seekers, religious and nonreligious persons.

“Our partnership with the Congressional Freethought Caucus has allowed us to advance the secular agenda in ways once unimaginable. By coordinating with the Caucus and their staff, we have been able to fight back against the erosion of the wall that separates religion and government and elevate the discussion of our common secular values in Congress. The entire coalition is thankful for the work the Congressional Freethought Caucus does, and we are excited to continue to work with them in the 117th Congress,” said Mark Dann, Director of Governmental Affairs at the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF).

The 19 member organizations who comprise the Secular Coalition for America will also be working to repeal the numerous harmful Executive Orders issued over the past four years. Also listed in the agenda are Trump Administration committees that have been used to blur the lines between religion and government, and advance the Christian Nationalist agenda. These include the Religious Liberty Task Force, which is dedicated to allowing religious institutions and individuals to continue to receive special treatment under the law, and the Commission on Unalienable Rights, led by well-known Christian Nationalist ally and current Secretary of State Mike Pompeo.

“The Trump Administration has used constitutionally suspect regulations and flagrant misinterpretations of U.S. Supreme Court decisions to promote religion, attack civil rights, and undermine the separation of religion and government. We look forward to working with the new administration to reverse these dangerous policies and to restore religious freedom for every American,” said Alison Gill, American Atheists Vice President for Legal and Policy.

“The assault on secular values reached an unprecedented level during the Trump administration. Trump and his religious extremist allies used every trick in the book to impose Christian nationalism upon every aspect of public life. The secular agenda we’ve presented here is the first step toward true separation of church and state, where the rights of nonbelievers receive equal weight and consideration,” said Jason Lemieux, Director of Government Affairs at the Center for Inquiry.

The Secular Coalition for America and our 19 member organizations look forward to continuing to advance our agenda to restore the secular nature of our government as guaranteed by the First Amendment to the Constitution. We also look forward to working with the members of the 117th Congress and the Biden administration to restore true religious freedom for all Americans.

# # #

CONTACT US

Spreading Happiness

Inventore curae facere aliquam convallis possimus quo laboriosam ullamco harum iaculis ipsa, consequuntur interdum aut officiis pulvinar doloribus auctor optio. Omnis diam natoque magnis, risus quam auctor porro ratione natus, eu arcu optio.

BECOME A SECULAR ACTIVIST

Sign up to receive updates and action alerts!

Scroll to Top